Welcome to Gay Nineties Pizza
At Gay Nineties Pizza, we celebrate the rich flavors of Italian cuisine in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Located in Pleasanton, CA, our establishment offers a delightful blend of full-bodied pizzas and appetizing dishes suitable for families, friends, and casual gatherings. With options that cater to both vegetarians and vegans, everyone is embraced at our tables. The menu boasts mouthwatering appetizers, hearty salads, and satisfying hot sandwiches, all crafted with fresh ingredients. Our outdoor seating and casual ambiance make it perfect for lunch or dinner. Join us for a fulfilling dining experience where flavor meets community!
- 288 Main St Pleasanton, CA 94566 United States Hotline: (925) 846-2520
Welcome to the delightful world of Gay Nineties Pizza, nestled in the heart of Pleasanton, California. This charming establishment invites you to indulge in the timeless pleasure of Italian cuisine, specifically crafted to honor the classic era of the 1890s.
At Gay Nineties Pizza, the focus is on creating a warm, casual atmosphere where both families and groups can enjoy an array of delectable offerings. With a menu that features not only mouthwatering pizzas but also a variety of appetizers, salads, and sandwiches, there is something for everyone.
- Appetizers: Start your meal with a platter of Antipasto or indulge in crispy Calamari Rings and savory Cheese Curds. Each dish bursts with authentic Italian flavors that set the stage for an unforgettable dining experience.
- Salads: Our selection of fresh salads includes the classic Cobb Salad and the refreshing Chicken Caesar Salad, perfect for those seeking a lighter option while still enjoying robust flavors.
- Hot Sandwiches: Dive into our hearty Italian Sausage and Mozzarella Sandwich or savor the rich taste of our Meatball and Mozzarella Sandwich. Vegan and vegetarian options are also readily available to accommodate diverse dietary preferences.
Beyond the impressive menu, Gay Nineties Pizza presents a host of utilities to ensure your enjoyment. Whether you're celebrating with friends or enjoying a simple family lunch, you can take advantage of features like outdoor seating, waiter service, and even dog-friendly spaces. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible and provides gender-neutral restrooms, catering to all guests.
For those who prefer to dine at home, Gay Nineties Pizza offers delivery and takeout services, making it convenient for every occasion. If you're looking to unwind with a drink, the restaurant serves beer and wine, enhancing your meal with the perfect pairing. And let's not forget about the warm, welcoming atmosphere filled with moderate noise that creates an inviting backdrop for great conversations and culinary delights.
As a food reviewer, I must emphasize the meticulous attention to detail and the passion for food that shines through in every dish at Gay Nineties Pizza. The fusion of flavors, coupled with the nostalgic ambiance, transports you back to a simpler time. I highly recommend experiencing the magic of this establishment for lunch or dinner, where every bite is a celebration of Italian heritage.
So grab your friends, bring the family, and indulge in delightful flavors at Gay Nineties Pizza, located at 288 Main St, Pleasanton, CA 94566. For reservations or inquiries, you can reach them at (925) 846-2520. Your taste buds will thank you!

This is a historical shop with stories. First time here, I was fascinated by the old fashioned decoration and old smell. It turned out to be a nice and cozy place to chat with friends while eating. The Chefs salad has good taste and ...

We came here for dinner and ordered Waynes World pizza. It took very long to get our food to our table, but it tasted very good! The aesthetic was very nice. It was very nice, though it was noisy and had no ...

First of all, the service here is always amazing. We had a server today, dont catch her name but she was super nice and made dining in even better. Best pizza Ive ever had! Other pizza places Ive been to never fill me up but with just 2 ...

Sunday crazy with large parties, yet the service and food were excellent. Its probably the best pizza Ive had there in 40 years. Kudos to whoever was making pies on Sunday!

Been coming here since I was a small child with my Dad, decades later it remains delicious. Their pizza is hearty and filling, and their specials are excellent. Make sure to order their house dressing with the salad.

Never been in Cali. Came here with my battle buddies and Estefany was Oustanding. The food and service was amazing. She dont even hesitate to split the bill to all of us. My Army family is grateful. Apreciated and definitely coming back

Ordered meatballs with pasta, two different types of pizza and sides of garlic bread. Thats enough to feed around 8 people. The restraunt does take reservations and that was nice and its lively enough in the restraunt you can still talk ...

We came here as a group for a birthday party. It was super packed but got seated quickly. It was very good pizza! Fresh ingredients and nice dough. The complimentary bread was a lil overcooked but thats fine cuz we were so hungry that we ...